What if the Dog Owner Claims their Dog has Never Bitten Anyone Before?

A dog bite can leave a victim with not only severe physical injuries but also a tangle of legal questions, especially when the dog owner insists their pet has never bitten anyone before. It’s a common defense, but one that doesn’t necessarily absolve the owner of responsibility. If you or a loved one has been injured in a dog attack, it’s important to understand how New Jersey law treats these claims and what your rights are as a victim.

New Jersey’s Dog Bite Law: It’s Not About the First Bite

New Jersey does not have a true “one bite rule,” meaning dog owners aren’t automatically off the hook just because their dog had no prior history of aggression. Instead, the state holds dog owners strictly liable for medical expenses if their dog bites someone—regardless of whether the dog had ever bitten anyone before. In more serious cases involving severe injuries or apparent negligence, a victim may also pursue additional damages such as lost wages, pain and suffering, or emotional distress.

So, even if a dog owner claims, “My dog has never done this before,” that doesn’t eliminate your right to seek compensation. What matters most is the nature of the injuries and whether the dog owner failed to take reasonable precautions to prevent the attack.

Steps to Take If the Owner Claims the Dog Has No History of Biting

If you’re injured and the dog owner defends their pet by claiming it’s the first time the dog has bitten someone, here’s what you should do:

1. Seek immediate medical attention. Always prioritize your health and create a documented record of your injuries.
2. Report the incident to your local police or animal control agency. This helps create an official report.
3. Gather evidence such as photographs of injuries, the scene of the attack, and damaged clothing.
4. Get the dog owner’s contact and vaccination information. Even if they claim it was the dog’s first bite, you still have the right to know the dog’s health status.
5. Contact a skilled dog bite attorney. A lawyer can help you understand the law, build your case, and deal with insurance companies that may try to minimize your claim.

How DiBartolo Law Can Help You After a Dog Bite

At DiBartolo Law, we understand the physical, emotional, and financial toll a dog attack can have. Even if the dog owner insists it was a first-time incident, our legal team can investigate the case, prove liability, and fight for the compensation you deserve. Don’t let the owner’s defense prevent you from getting justice.

Contact DiBartolo Law today for a free consultation and let our experienced dog bite lawyer help you take the next steps toward recovery. Call us or contact us online now to get started.